The Saga of the People of Reykjadal and Killer-Skuta (Ep. 19): Almost all of the candidates for notable witticism for this saga come from chapter 26, which is a bit odd. The problem here is that this chapter is identical to Viga-Glum’s Saga and likely lifted from that source. We only had two legitimate candidates not from that chapter, but we quickly dismissed one of those. Debate ensued concerning whether or not to give the prize to one of the witticisms from Viga-Glum’s Saga or to not award a Notable Witticism at all. We ultimately convinced ourselves to award Glum for observing that Skuta might be the better fighter when they are evenly matched and then quipping “But I’m not about to run out onto your sword.” It tickled us enough to pull out the win.
The Saga of Finnbogi the Strong (Ep. 18): John and Andy agreed that the narrator saved the best lines for himself in this saga. Part of the problem with this saga was a distinct lack of direct speech. It’s no surprise that the saga narrator took the prize here with his stunning personification of the 6 stones Finnbogi sent against Brand’s farmhands. Finnbogi’s own farmhands, his stones, use both agility and force to dispatch each of Brand’s men. When Finnbogi asks what Brand thinks of his farmhands, the stones, Brand says he can’t find any fault in them. It’s an unusual candidate for Notable Witticism, but just clever enough to win our votes.
The Saga of the Greenlanders (Ep. 17): Due to a lack of wit in the saga, Andy abstained from voting, which is a Saga Thing first. With freedom to choose his favorite and crown the winner, John scraped the bottom of the barrel, as is his wont. He offered up Freydis’ “Hand me an axe” as a bit of black humor, but not terribly convincingly. With John at her back, Freydis won this award easily.
Grettir’s Saga (Ep. 16): So many good candidates in this saga. It’s incredibly unfair that we could only choose one, but those are the rules. Grettir’s rather impressive “penis poems” more than compensated for any shortcomings he might have had. His wit clearly charmed our filthy minds, so we gave him the award (tittering and giggling all the while).
Quarter Court Results (Ep. 15): A tight race between Egil Skulason’s [“I don’t find it funny, though your servants laugh about it, when you sit with your legs tight, rubbing your thighs together”] in Bandamanna Saga and Kormak’s “What will you sorcerers think of next?” Kormak won the day by 2% of the popular vote.
Vatnsdœla Saga (Ep. 14): This saga teems with more than just bloodshed and nicknames. It’s also got a lot of great witticisms. The favorites were Thorkel Scratcher’s childish response to Thorgrim’s question, “What are you looking at?” and Hrolleif bluntly, but accurately, announcing Ingimund’s cause of death as “He was used as a target.” In the end, we opted to reward Jokul Ingimundarsson’s legal acumen, evidenced when he responded to Ottar’s charges against Ingolf by saying “we will render this case void with our axe-hammers.” This charming fellow didn’t get picked for thingman or any other category, but he goes home with a nice shiny Notable Witticism trophy for his mantel.
Viglund’s Saga (Ep. 13): With the author’s focus on romance and consent theory, he forgot that saga characters should have a sharp wit. The only one to really say anything that fits our criteria for this category was Thorgrim, father of Viglund and Trausti. When the two brothers are returning home from the games, Thorgrim notices the bandaging around Viglund’s head. Knowing that it must have come from either Einar or Jokul of Foss, he wonders why Viglund didn’t retaliate. Rather than asking him directly, he simply says: “Welcome home my son and daughter.” While a modern and more sensitive audience might think of this as gender shaming, we thought it rather witty for this little romance.
The Saga of Bjorn Champion of the Hitardal People (Ep. 12): This was a full category with plenty of strong candidates like the cow verse and the grey-belly verses. Ultimately, the prize went to Bjorn’s mother, Thordis. After Thord tosses her the gore encrusted head of her son, she looks the coward in the eye and boldly heaps some much deserved scorn upon him: “I know the head and you should know it too, for you have often gone in fear before that head when it was still attached to the body. Go now and take it to Oddny, she’ll like it better than that wretched little thing hanging from your neck.” You go, girl.
Kormak’s Saga (Ep. 11): Kormak wins with his exasperated response to the lengthy catalog of rituals that accompany the proper use of the sword Skofnung. “What will you sorcerers think of next?” We liked it so much, we put it on a shirt and a mug in our store: http://sagathingpodcast.spreadshirt.com/
Hallfred Troublesome-Poet’s Saga (Ep. 10): How could a poetic accusation of bestiality lose this one? Really.
Scarcely will the white fellow stride,
helmet-slicing, by the pantry
(he will go without the Eir Eir (goddess) of coins: woman, Kolfinna
of coins), nor the grey dog Strut,
though the scythe-shover,
unlovely, has a wide milking-shed
(the sword-plain’s keeper enjoys sword-plain: shield, its keeper: warrior or man, Gris
his livestock) and a long sheep-pen.
Gunnlaug Serpent-Tongue’s Saga (Ep. 9): We like Gunnlaug’s bumper sticker slogan “One mustn’t limp while both legs are the same length.”
Bandamanna saga (Ep. 8): Was there ever any doubt? In a saga justly famous for its clever writing, the win goes to Egil Skulason and Thorarin of Laugardal for their confrontation at the Judgment Circle: As Thorarin gets up to argue with Egil, Egil snaps, “Shut up and sit down, Thorarin, don’t say a word, or I’ll accuse you of such shameful things that it would be better for you to keep silent. I don’t find it funny, though your servants laugh about it, when you sit with your legs tight, rubbing your thighs together.” Thorarin’s response? “Wisdom is welcome, wherever it comes from.” And he sat down and kept quiet.
Saga of Ragnar Lothbrok and his Sons (Ep. 7): No judgments here, but there are some good ones. We’ll let you decide. Here are a few to consider: 1) Ragnar’s men are shocked by the beauty of Kraka (Aslaug) and disgusting appearance of the evil woman, Grima, who poses as her mother – “We have never seen a maiden so beautiful, and we don’t think that she looks anything like you, because you are the greatest monstrosity.” 2) Ivar the Boneless has a strategy for defeating Sibilja the Swedish cow. It goes a little something like this – “When that cow comes at us, throw me at her, and one of two things will happen: either I shall lay down my life, or else she will get her death.” 3) While dying in the snake pit, Ragnar gets off his best line of the saga – “The piglets would grunt now, if they knew how the old pig suffers.”
Hen-Thorir’s Saga (Ep. 6): Several good options here. Helgi’s posthumously composed poem “Brenni, brenni Blund-Ketil inni” was a strong contender. In the end, we chose Thorkel’s witty back and forth with Gunnar’s slave on a cold cold night. After the slave tells Thorkel to either come in and go straight to bed or to leave, Thorkel offers two options of his own: “Either go and do […] as you’re told or I’ll bounce the hilt of my sword off your nose.” How could we pass that up?
Gisli’s saga Sursson (Ep. 5): After the Vesteinssons assassinate Thorkel Sursson at the Thorskafjord Thing and are in mid-escape, they are hailed and questioned by Thorkel’s friend Bork about what’s happening. Helgi Vesteinsson, without slowing down, responds, “I think they’re arguing about whether Vestein left only daughters behind, or whether he had a son”–a laudable combination of wit and defiance that makes for a satisfying winner.
Eirik the Red’s saga (Ep. 4): We were both impressed with Thorvald Eiriksson’s aplomb as he lay dying from an arrow-shot to the groin. “This is a rich country we have found,” he says to Karlsefni once the arrow is removed. “There is plenty of fat around my entrails.”
Eyrbyggja Saga (Ep. 3): The character-study of Thorarin Black’s slow collapse into panic in the aftermath of his rage-fueled killing of Thorbjorn Stout is definitely worth a closer examination. But both John and Andy agree that Katla the Witch’s jealous mocking of Gunnlaug Thorbjarnason’s attentions to Geirrid (Thorarin Black’s mother, who also happens to be a witch) takes the prize, particularly her inquiry as to whether Gunnlaug is “off to stroke the old hag up the belly?”
Hrafnkel’s saga (Ep. 2): Andy offers Thorgeir Thjostarsson’s complaint in response to his brother Thorkel having arranged for old Thorbjorn to grab Thorgeir’s sore foot. Thorkel makes an eloquent speech comparing Thorgeir’s pain to Thorbjorn’s much greater pain at the loss of his son Einar. Thorgeir’s response: “I didn’t kill his son, so there’s no need for him to take it out on me.”
John prefers Sám’s resentful acceptance of his uncle Thorbjorn’s lawsuit against the formidable Hrafnkel Freysgoði: “I’m very reluctant to bring an action against Hrafnkel. I’ll do so only because we’re kinsmen, but I want you to know that in my opinion I’m helping a fool in helping you.”