At long last, it is time to put Grettir’s Saga on trial. Does the fight atop a whale carcass have enough appeal to win Best Bloodshed? Will Grettir’s Saga break the Body Count record currently held by Eyrbyggja Saga? Will Andy and John outlaw Grettir or take him on as thingman? Does Andy finally decide whether Grettir’s Saga is better or worse than Gisli’s Saga? And will John ever stop talking about Nicknames? This saga is full of memorable moments, witticisms, and wonders, which is why this judgment section ended up being so long. But don’t worry, there’s plenty to laugh about and plenty to learn here.
Gisli’s saga
Episode 16c – Grettir’s Saga (Part 3)
The Saga of Grettir the Strong continues. In this episode, Grettir arrives home in Iceland only to discover that his father has passed away, his brother has been slain by Thorbjorn Oxen-might, and that he himself has been outlawed for the accidental burning of Thorir of Gard’s sons in Norway. That’s a lot to take in all at once. As an outlaw, Grettir is forced to lurk in the wilds, hide in caves, and rely on the kindness of others for food. Since Grettir’s not terribly kind himself, he usually just steals what he needs. Join us as we discuss the last of Grettir’s adventures, including amazing feats of strength, battles with a troll-hag and a giant, and a rocky encounter with a witch. Will Grettir get stumped by the witch’s black magic? Will he go out in a blaze of glory? And will he ever recover from the embarrassment of his exposed manhood? Find out in this episode of Saga Thing.

Drangey Island in Skagafjörður fjord, where Grettir and Illugi spent their final years.
Download this episode (right click and save)
Pick up a copy of Grettir’s Saga and discover what we left out!
Episode 16b – Grettir’s Saga (Part 2)
In this episode we follow Grettir through three of his most famous battles against an undead Kar the Old, a giant Norwegian bear, and Iceland’s most famous draugr, Glam. We also catch Grettir stumbling in a clumsy fight for fire that will eventually seal his fate as an outlaw forever. This one runs a little longer than the average episode of Saga Thing, but with so much excellent material to cover, we just couldn’t resist.
Download this episode (right click and save)
Pick up a copy of Grettir’s Saga and discover all that we left out!
Episode 16 – Grettir’s Saga (Part 1)

Download this episode (right click and save)

Pick up a copy of Grettir’s Saga and discover all the stuff we left out!
Episode 13a – The Saga of Viglund the Fair

Episode 12b – The Saga of Bjorn Champion of the Hitardal People (Judgments)
In the second part of Saga Thing’s look at The Saga of Bjorn Champion of the Hitardal People, John and Andy discuss the merits of the text, argue over the size and ferocity of the dragon, investigate Thord’s ill-fated encounter with a stranded seal, and share some interesting tidbits from Icelandic law codes about pornographic sculptures and naughty poetry. We also outlaw a rather deserving villain, choose our thingmen, and offer our thoughts on the saga’s overall quality. It’s a full episode with a nice balance of humor, scholarship, and speculation.
If you’re interested in learning more about the Icelandic legal definitions of níð and ýki as they relate to Bjorn’s Saga, follow this link to Alison Finlay’s excellent article on the subject: Monstrous Allegations: An Exchange of ýki in Bjarnar saga Hítdælakappa.
Gísla saga poll–Murder in the Dark
The holiday break has us scrambling to finish our eggnog and get to work on Hen-Thorir’s saga. In the meantime, here’s your chance to weigh in on the great mystery at the heart of our last saga: Who slipped silently into Gísli’s house and plunged the spear Grasida into Vestein Vesteinsson’s chest? We’ve come to our own conclusions (which you can hear about in episode 5B), but at least one saga writer disagrees with us. Did we convict the wrong man for the crime, or was our argument convincing enough to justify our outlawry choice? Or did we (and Gísli) miss the boat entirely, allowing a third conspirator (Thorgrim Nef, the sorcerous blacksmith who reforged the shattered sword Grasida into the fatal spearhead) to get away with murder? It’s your call…
Episode 5b – Gisli’s Saga (Judgments)
It’s time to judge Gisli’s Saga. Join John and Andy on a tour through the saga’s best bloodshed, body count, nicknames, and notable witticisms. The titular character of Eirik’s the Red’s Saga was outlawed last time, will it happen again to Gisli? Or will Andy defend him against the charges of murder and claim him as thingman? Find out in this episode of Saga Thing.
Download this episode (right click and save)
We’ll be back in January with The Saga of Hen-Thorir. Check it out here:
Episode 5a – Gisli’s Saga
We’re back from our unanticipated end-of-semester hiatus, and this time we’re tackling one of the true giants of saga literature–join us as we explore the world of the outlaw Gisli Sursson and his siblings in the tumultuous Gisli’s saga!
Gisli Sursson’s Saga and the Saga of the People of Eyri (Penguin Classics)
This saga tells the tragic story of Gisli Sursson, whose profound sense of honor forces him into violent action designed to hurt his own brother. Not surprisingly, this leads to a sentence of outlawry. Whereas most Icelanders who are branded outlaws flee the land to seek their fortune abroad, Gisli refuses to stray far from his wife, Aud Vesteinsdottir. Hunted by enemies who seek to exploit his link to Aud, Gisli must escape the clutches of Bork the Stout and his team of bounty hunters (Eyjolf the Grey, Helgi the Spy, Outlaw-Stein, Thorgrim the Norwegian, and others) time and time again. Join us as we review one of Icelandic literature’s most endearing and heroic characters as we call Gisli’s Saga to the Saga Thing!
Episode 3b: Eyrbyggja Saga (Judgments)
In this second go at Eyrbyggja saga, we answer the burning questions left unasked by our first episode:
Will Thrand Stigandi’s ostentatious attack at Ospak’s farm be enough to win Best Bloodshed?
How many bodies hit the floor, and why is it so difficult to come up with a consistent count?
In a saga with names like Thorstein Cod-Biter, Thorolf Bladder-bald, and Sigurð Snake-in-the-Eye, who can possibly win Best Nickname?
Who will be banished from Iceland forever?
Will Andy get to honor his hero Snorri by choosing him as thingman?
What do we really think of Eyrbyggja Saga?
Find out in the latest installment of Saga Thing!
Download this episode (right click and save)
Get in on the action and let us know who you would choose for your thingman: